Flip Mino - only for new parents?
I just got a Flip Mino video camera (it was a gift). I'm still trying to decide if it is worth it...
I knew about these video cameras from my friends with babies. For some reason, everyone I know that has a baby buys one of these things.
I just showed it to one of my other friends and he thought it was amazing. He even offered to buy it off of me (I refused). I'll run through what I see as the pros/cons, then I'll explain why I'm still not sure if it is worth it.
What is it?
- Small camcorder that plugs directly to your computer via a built-in USB plug.
- Records an hour of video
- The new model (Mino) has a built-in rechargeable battery
- The device comes with software that helps the user do minor editing of the video (e.g., crop beginning/end of video). It also has some video templates to jazz up the video.
- The software has a very simple upload-to-YouTube feature that doesn't even require saving the video to your computer first.
- It sells for $159 on Amazon. (the HD version sells for $207 on Amazon)
Pros:
- It is small and light. Definitely smaller than a normal camcorder.
- It is simple. Just point and record, then plug into your computer. There aren't even any cables.
- Even the software is simple. It provides some basic editing and simple sharing options.
- The rechargeable battery is nice.
- Users can share and upload videos without using a separate video editing app like iMovie.
- It has a simple upload-to-YouTube feature, which makes it super easy to share videos
Cons:
- It is light - feels a little plastic-y and cheap.
- The video quality is ok, not great. And when using their upload-to-YouTube feature, it compresses the video first and the quality s-u-c-k-s when you watch it on YouTube. (I got better quality by doing a higher quality export from iMovie, then uploading to YouTube).
- Unless you buy a separate cable, to charge the camera, you need to leave it plugged into your computer for a few hours.
- The editing software is basic, which is good for some people. But for me, it is a little too wimpy. At a minimum, I like to add titles and transitions, but the software doesn't support this.
To buy or not to buy?
To decide if it is worth it, you need to compare it to something. Most people compare it to a normal camcorder. Yes, for the average person, it is much more convenient than a normal camcorder. A normal camcorder requires a video editing application which can import the video from the camera, then requires saving the right parts as a video clip. The Mino is much easier than that.
But I think that is the wrong comparison. What you should really compare it to is a point-and-shoot camera that also records video. Most people carry these around anyway. I have used my point and shoot camera to record a lot of snowboarding video since it is a small device - and it has the benefit of taking very high rez photos.
Compared to a point and shoot camera, the benefits of the Mino aren't so great. The transfer of video is already pretty simple with a point and shoot camera. The video quality of the Mino is equal (or maybe a little worse). And the Mino doesn' treally take still photos (but you can create a still photo from a frame of the video, but the quality is very bad).
So the real difference comes down to the software that comes with the Mino. If you want an easy way to go directly from the device to YouTube, this might work for you - if you are happy with very low quality video. If you never do any fancy editing, the software might meet your needs.
I'm going to play with it more, and I'm going to test the video quality vs. my point and shoot camera (for a future post). So far, it isn't compelling for a guy like me, but I already know my dad would love it for the simplicity.
Anyone have other opinions?



